Dips   
Member since: May 05
Posts: 97
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 21-05-05 10:55:01

Hi Rajan

Yes it is absolutely true that there has been noticeable change in India, specially with private sector participation.

Phone connection- You can get it within 30 minutes if you go for reliance or tata or other private service provider. Not only in cities but most of the small towns as well, as these are wireless phone work on CDMA technology. In canada it took me more than 20 days to get line. Bell canada guys were on strike. Very surprising

Banking: I had great experience in banking. Here it takes 4 hrs to open an account. ICICI bank account opening takes hardly half an hour with their ready made bank opening kit. Plus you will find ATM counters at ever corner of the roads. Here there are lots of hidden cost in every thing and in banking here you have to maintain minimum balance even for checking account or pay high charges for self service and full service.

Malls and picture halls: Lots of malls have come up and multiplex picture hall and lots of things are happening now a days.

Intercity highways are being developed with four lane highways. For most of the cities four lane highways are complete. Mumbai Pune is a6 lane highway is truly world class.

The problem area is still the areas controlled by govt which hurts. Jammed city, buses, trains, and other services provided by govt still hurts.

However, other good thing happening is that India is slowly opening up and in next 10 years when most of the reforms are in place, there will be sudden growth in india's economy. Presently we are maintaining 7% growth and after 10 year it will touch 9-10% which is really great growth. Mckinsey has said even if India grows at 6.5% then by 2030 it will third biggest economy in the world after US, China.

I am not sure what will happen to Canada by that time. Probably more and more immigrant coming in here. Labor rates going further down from 8$/hr to may be 6$ / hr. Life becoming still more difficult as no major inverstments are happening in this country. More and more lay offs can could be the future of this country.

All rich countries are now focussing there future investments in BRIC countries- Brazil, Russia, India and China.

So richer countries like US, UK, Canada would still get richer but all their operations and services will be in BRIC. Which means these companies would still have their HQ in US, UK, France but all jobs shifted to BRIC countries. The companies will go richer but people will go poorer as lacs of job at lower level will shift to these countries. Only top management will have good jobs and for lower level there might not be enough jobs.

BRIC is also forming its own Trade barriers to counter trade barriers of NAFTA, EU etc etc...

So it would be interesting to see the future which as per all belongs to ASIA.

It won't be surprising to see in next 10-15 yrs people filing immigration visa for INDIA and CHINA.

So good decision taken Interceptor. People will follow you in future.



bhaskararayan   
Member since: Aug 08
Posts: 1
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 01-09-08 00:26:57

Quote:
Originally posted by Interceptor

After a long struggle in canada and doing menial jobs for about 3 years ...thinking one day i will get a job not of my choice but some thing related to my field.

I then decided to do some backward integration and started applying from here in other countries in Asia.

Finally I was given an opportunity by my old employer as he knew the scene in canada with almost comfortable salary.

He appreciated my Hardwork which i had done during my stay earlier and he welcomed me again..well may be people say that never look back but i would definately say " Always look back, may be somebody need you"

My analysis...

Canada is not of educated personnels...
If u want to settle in canada you sacrifice lots of things in life not for short period but for more than 5 years...(most case)

To my surprise while i was going back in same flight i found 2 more couples going back permenantly ...


I would not be often writing this to all as i may have limited access to internet due to busy schedule in my new professional position.

I would say ALL THE BEST for those who are there and SAYONARA ..GOOD BYE ALL...


If given chance in future ( if i get a job in my field) i will think of returning but not for Menial jobs any more....

Thanks god!!! I am out of it finally!!!



---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This is a false story doing rounds as a genuine pathetic story.Many epople who are here in Canada after reading this are disturbed.

Following inconsistencies are observed in the story.I will deal with the original story posted elsewhere too but first what is posted here.

Piecemeal analysis:
---------------------

"Finally I was given an opportunity by my old employer as he knew the scene in canada with almost comfortable salary.

He appreciated my Hardwork which i had done during my stay earlier and he welcomed me again..well may be people say that never look back but i would definately say " Always look back, may be somebody need you" "

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observation:

The possibility of getting a job even in India after working for 3 years in odd jobs in Canada is remote and that too for a specialied area like Software engineering as the person mentions elsewhere.

These three years of working in odd jobs the person's software skills would have become rusty.Software is an area where skills need updation every year or maybe even a shorter time-frame.

Tactics used: Our-people-better-than-people-here psychology, emotional issue sidetracking

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Finally I was given an opportunity by my old employer as he knew the scene in canada with almost comfortable salary."

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Observation:

What is the preciseness of "almost comfortable salary". It is vague.
Also, assuming a comfortable salary was given. Why would the old employer,unless he is a relative of the person, give a comfortable salary based on some work the person had done 3 years ago?

Tactics used here: Vagueness of statements to kep i all openended, temptation for change and comfort
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Canada is not of educated personnels...
If u want to settle in canada you sacrifice lots of things in life not for short period but for more than 5 years...(most case)"
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observation:

If a devloped country like Canada is not for educated people, then I fail to understand which country is for educated people? Somalia or Ethiopia?(With due respects to those nations)

Regarding sacrificing thins in life: No pain no gain. Yes, you do miss your home country initially but then the other benefits would outweigh the losses.

Also, 5 years is a long time. I know many people who have either come with a job or who have got a job in a matter of weeks after coming here.

5 years is quoted to depress the mind of the reader.(Nfearious intent not backed by a statistical reasoning or proof)

Tactics used here: Emotional issue,commonplace issues blown out of proportion, inflating time-lines and playing with facts a bit to support the main-line point.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"To my surprise while i was going back in same flight i found 2 more couples going back permenantly ..."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Observation:

This is called in the study of logic: Prominence to emotional issues to side-track the main line of argument or hypothesis.

When you quote other people(of the same community/creed/caste/country) doing the same, you invoke the innate relief in the reader and incite him to do the same using an emotional tool.Also, herd-mentality innate in humans is also kindled here.

Tactics used here: Herd mentality,prominence to emotional issues
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~


"I would not be often writing this to all as i may have limited access to internet due to busy schedule in my new professional position."

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Observation: This is to give an indirect hint(innuendo to speak logically) that the person is :Happy, busily engaged(note the words "new professional position";) and that all others can take cue from him.Also, it creates what is called the "force of scarcity" in the minds of readers, that his opinions have been typed fast, emotionally, genuinely,etc because he is not available like a commoner and thus arrogates himself to a higher level than the reader of the post.

The tactics used here: Innuendo, time-duress for the reader.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"I would say ALL THE BEST for those who are there and SAYONARA ..GOOD BYE ALL..."

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Observation: This creates the feeling in the reader for a wistful want to be in his shoes and to experience the same relief and joy. It is always greener on the other side of the river.

The use of a japanese word "Sayanora"(a Old Hindi film song) is to create a sense of comaderie and humour in a positive manner to impress the reader psychologically

Tactics used: Creation of a desire emotionally, friendlines of tone.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"If given chance in future ( if i get a job in my field) i will think of returning but not for Menial jobs any more....

Thanks god!!! I am out of it finally!!! "
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Observation: The words "Menial jobs" have been used cleverly again here, to drill a concept that "Those who come to Canada leaving India have to do menial jobs and comprmise on their self-respect eternally" This is farthest from the truth.

Also, carefully note the words in the bracket :"if I get a job in my field": This is done to showcase a possibility that the chance of getting a job in Canada in his(read the reader's field too) is remote.

The use of the words "Thanks God!!! I am out of it finally!!!" : again tends to incite a feeling of comfort and relief in the outcome and make the readr imagine his joy and comfort

Tactics used: Redundancy of argument, emotional stances used, use of psychological devices (within brackets as this will not be missed)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Final analysis and probable intent of the sender of the message:

1. A prankster who takes a perverted pleasure in playing with the feeling sof Indians in Canada.

2. A person who lives in Canada/USA and yet tries to act smart or funny by doling out this message to perturb the reader's minds.

3. Eliminate atleast soem competition for him, when such an emotional story is quoted.

4. A person who had really gone back to India for some other unreveable reasons and acts in a jealous manner to confuse Indian readers here.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

I hope you all enjoyed my analysis.

My opinion: Ths story is false and once needs to be upbeat and confident in life anywhere in the world to become a success.



brown_bear   
Member since: Nov 06
Posts: 542
Location: Somewhere in dreamland

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 01-09-08 02:40:55

Interesting Analysis. The guy (Interceptor) who posted earlier saying he's leaving Canada for good and says he's not recommending any one to immigrate to Canada (posted in 2005) is back in canada and lives in Etobicoke (in 2007) and is posting in Canadian desi to meet couples friends!!!

So can I assume he(Interceptor) wants to be in Canada but doesn't want others to come here?



spaceman   
Member since: Feb 07
Posts: 108
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 01-09-08 15:36:36

Hi bhaskararayan, you have done an awesome analysis of the post by interceptor. There are many people around who enjoy in demoralizing others and create a feeling of negativity. He himself is back in Canada after leaving (as mentioned on the above post). Though it takes time and effort to settle in Canada, BUT its not impossible. I know some of the CD's here who are working in very reputed companies and are always helping others. They too have found jobs in short period and instead of demoralizing people they always help them when ever asked for.

Anyway bhaskararayan once again nice analysis. Keep it up.......:cheers:



son-of-india   
Member since: Nov 04
Posts: 214
Location: india

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 04-10-08 00:49:47

tihs guy interceptor seems to be guy from anti immigrant group. who has a knack ofusing emotional words to discourage others here. :cuss:



karais   
Member since: May 04
Posts: 2
Location: Now in scarbarough

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 09-10-08 21:48:16

It is in black and white.. as to what living and working in Canada is.. If you do not know.. you must have asked your friends.. even before you immigrate. As is rightly mentioned.. people with less communication skills decide to go back. But the very reason they immigrated to Canada was they were not successful in their own country.

This guy.. has stayed for three years or more.. Do you know why.. because he must have decided take his citizenship.. Trust me.. they yearn for this Citizenship.

Yes.. it is true..they do come back.. and honestly they will never be successful.

They need to improve their skills and know how to face life.

Karais



prasad_vara1   
Member since: Mar 07
Posts: 10
Location:

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 07-12-08 08:37:33

Hi Dear Bhaskararayan and Karais


As you are aware( I hope f you are aware) that every body have freedom to express their opinion with in the limits. So what is wrong with Interceptor in expressing his experience and opinion about life in Canada.

Bhaskararayan, I pity with your analysis and by the way are u a Immigration lawyer? Immigration lawyers want to put rosy picture about Canada, so that they can get more clients. I think you are one of those blood sucking immigration lawyers.

before making any comment, just check the immigration statistics and find how many of immigrants hv success stories in terms of percentage. Very few success stories. You people quote success stores of few people and try to hide failure stories many.

Hi Karais, do you think that only communication skills will get you job? Of course, u will get low paid jobs like Call centers and Wall marts etc as customer support rep. If you are happy with $10 / hour odd jobs, then yes you are successful and your communication skills got you such a beautiful job( :clap: :down: ).

People who forced to work for 10 to 15 hours in odd jobs to meet their bills, talks big when they come to India on short trip( hahahaa, poor Canadian NRI). he thinks that people at back home does not know what they are doing in Canada. hahhaaa, dear brother, you are wrong. we know what you are doing there in Canada.

So if you want to fool your self, carry on, but do not thick that you can fool others by your artificial Canadian accent.




Discussions similar to: Good Bye Canada...I m back in India

Topic Forum Views Replies
Sticky: Old Doordarshan Serials ! Your Pick ? ( 1 2 3 ... Last )
Filmi Gupshup 195415 193
DRIVER’S HANDBOOK NOTES
Just Landed 5540 2
An Angry letter from a young lady made JRD Tata change his rule - A story by Sud ( 1 2 )
Our Native Country! 3769 9
Top Eight Reasons NOT to immigrate to Canada ** ( 1 2 3 ... Last )
Jobs 65389 324
It's a Flat World, After All
News and Events 1879 0
Top Eight Reasons NOT to immigrate to Canada ( 1 2 3 4 )
Moving Soon 9230 27
Think Big + Indian Style = Reliancestan != INDIA # 1
Our Native Country! 1759 1
More power to consumer
Our Native Country! 1746 0
Mukesh Ambanis Blue Print for Reliance in SEZ & Retail - India #1
Our Native Country! 1869 0
Tata wins Corus bid
Our Native Country! 1546 0
Drug Design/Research/Development: Outsourced to India
Our Native Country! 4119 3
Social Darwinism-Survival of the Fittest & Trickle-down Economics ( 1 2 3 ... Last )
News and Events 39226 229
India's Nice, but Tata wants more
Our Native Country! 2190 4
Investpro's finance/economy newspicks ( 1 2 3 ... Last )
News and Events 24350 101
Lease agreement- Problem at the end of lease ( 1 2 3 )
Real Estate & Mortgages 9221 20
CELL NUMBER PORTABLITY - MY EXPERIENCE WITH BELL CANADA
General 2899 6
From Globe & Mail
News and Events 2278 4
Dark Side of Dubai !
General 3640 4
President Obama's speech at Cairo University ( 1 2 )
General 1854 7
The Best Answers to Tough Interview Questions ( 1 2 3 4 )
Jobs 10479 24
Is university worth it ?
Study 2815 1
TN Visa to Green Card ( 1 2 3 4 5 )
USA 9547 31
Crony Capitalism of RIL ( 1 2 )
Our Native Country! 3807 9
Express Entry NEW. EDIT 14 28th JANUARY 2019. ( 1 2 )
Independent Category 15698 8
WHODATHUNKIT ( 1 2 3 )
General 9186 17
 


Share:
















Advertise Contact Us Privacy Policy and Terms of Usage FAQ
Canadian Desi
© 2001 Marg eSolutions


Site designed, developed and maintained by Marg eSolutions Inc.