Is immigration to Canada really worth it??


Jump to Page:
< Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >



NorthAlberta   
Member since: Jul 04
Posts: 195
Location: Beef and Bacon Country

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 24-07-04 17:35:25

Just move out fast if doubts are in your mind


-----------------------------------------------------------------
"Ever dance with the devil in the pale moon light?"
"I always ask that of all my prey."
"I just like the sound of it."


deepcb   
Member since: Mar 04
Posts: 142
Location: Dubai

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 25-07-04 07:17:20

Hi,

I would appreciate whatever you had written, but would like to express my views......

Lots of people migrating from India like to know what are the chances of success...I have seen people comment on success stories and failures.

What we should look for is ....what percentage people succeeded and failed.

I am sure there are 20% highly successful people, 40% average people and say 40% failure.

Everyone is not fortunate as you to turn everything into GOLD as you did. If thats the case, you would have been successful even if you had gone to Uganada. You are one of those extremely fortunate ones to be successful in short time in Canada.

I am talking about an average Middle Class Indian who migrates....We have few categories of people :

1. Technician level/ Blue Collar job
2. Average Clerical / Officer Category
3. Professional (Engineer/CA etc)
4. Highly Highly skilled (Rocket Scientist, CGFS Nurses, FRCS Doctors)

Category 1 : Has a low quality of life in India, despite good skills..like Welders, Trailer driver, Crane Operator, Fitters, X ray Technicians etc. These people will get good jobs in Canada and will settle down in short period of time. 80% success rate.

Category 2 : Has a BA or B.com doing clerical job in India...willing to do any entry level job in Canada..from Data entry to customer service @ $ 10 per hour...most likely to get odd jobs and will survive...success rate 70%

Category 3 : Is a University Graduate..has good job in India ..good salary..in few years time will be a Manager...some of them are already....have reasonably comfortable life in India. These kind of jobs are highly paid in Canada...$ 70 k plus. Difficult for Canadians to accept Asians since these are supervisory / senior level jobs...Some survive for 2 / 3 years and succeed gradually..others fail...success rate 50%..depending on your age..the higher your age the more you fail.

Category 4 : Exceptional talent. Less Canadians available for that job..and lot of vacancies...most likely to succeed..success rate 90%

Hence its upto prospective Immigrants to decide where you fall. I would say....TRY AND FAIL...RATHER THAN NOT TRYING AT ALL......


Deep


U win some...loose some....everything is not justified in this world....









Quote:
Orginally posted by bighead

its all a matter of personal choices... yes there are a LOT of people who screwed themselves silly by coming here, but my personal view is, 90% of people who failed is because they didnt do their homework before they hopped onto a plane...

its very unfortunate that a LOT of desi's have incorrect expectations about migration which in my opinion is one of the leading factors as to why people have difficulties migrating... desi's come from a mindset where they dont really have any struggle (or any significant struggle) back home, things always come easy to a person when he or she has an established base already to build on such as family, friends etc... all migrants migrate because they aspire to be better (which is a good thing)... they assume they will be afforded the same facilities as they had back home which is never the case... even if you have close family or friends here you just cannot expect the same level of support you did back home from them...

the first and foremost reason why people run into problems is, they move to the wrong place... location location location... the choice of where you want to move to should be based on a number of factors, but almost ALL desi's i have seen make that choice based on what they hear from relatives, friends and other desi's and their experiences, which may not be applicable in their situation... very very simple example is this one guy i know from gujrat who is a geologist with 7 years experience and had initially migrated to toronto because his sister and brother in law were there... he did not take time out to do his research to see how adaptable he will be based on his skills if he moved to toronto... lest to say he worked in a factory for a year on minimum wage... thankfully though he is now employed by an oil company in fort mcmurray in alberta...

the next thing is the skills the desi's bring to where they are going... again as an example, java programmers moving to toronto where there are hundred other java programmers already there without employment... what else can you expect? bottom line is, these days, not just in canada but like any other country with a mature economy, employers have a wide variety of candidates to pick and choose from... and they obviously want to get the best value for their dollar... a lot of desi's dont think about what they can do to make their employment prospects better in a new country.. they automatically assume that they are good enough as they are and are unwilling to be flexible... and then things dont work out the way they want it to, untimately end up blaming lack of canadian experience (which i agree is a important factor - but it can still be overcome, it all depends on how you package and present yourself) or they blame the whites for being racist against them or they feel sorry they didnt go to US instead because their friends in US are better off etc etc...

also, what i have started noticing in people who move to canada is, they try to get experiences of others specially on the internet, and most of the things they read there are bad... its usually a person who has failed in canada who will rant and rave the loudest about how he was screwed by this country and how he should never have come here... there are very very very few posts on the internet about the success stories (and there are a LOT of success stories) and unfortunately reading all these negative experiences, we set ourselves up for failure... we come here expecting to fail (but obviously hoping to succeed) and in that state of mind unfortunately are not able to recognize any oppurtunities they present themselves, or become too timid to make new oppurtunities for ourselves...

bottom line is, once you move to a new place, you have to be flexible and adaptable to the new place, and that includes the society and culture... we come from a mindset where it is the husbands responsibility to provide for the house and the wife takes care of the house... in canada, you need a two income household in most cases.. unfortunately, a lot of the wives who come here are too timid to become involved in the income generation process, just because they have never had to do it back home... this is just a simple example of the need to be flexible...

and biggest thing, you just CANNOT model another person's experience and expect you will go through the same thing... each individual case is different... two people with the exact same situation in the exact same place will have two different stories to tell...

as far as success stories go, there are a LOT of them... for one, i personally am one... we are financially secure, we own our house (its amazing how much faster you can pay off your mortgage if you just double your payments and make the occasional prepayment)... i run my own ERP services company with 4 big name oil and gas clients, and moving to canada was the best thing that has happened to me and my family.... when we first came to canada my wife was four months pregnant and i had US$455 in cash and US$1000 in travellers checks (borrowed money to show as landing funds which i returned a week after we got here) and i knew NOONE when i moved, no family or friends even in the same province... closest relative i had was a cousin in another province...

i must admit, i have been very lucky... by the grace of god, everything i have touched since coming here has become gold... but i also know i am not the only one... there are a LOT of people who have had similar success that i have had... some are real estate agents, some own their own businesses, some are into IT... from various backgrounds...

when did we move to canada? 5 and a half years ago...

ps: sorry for rambling on and on ::-)


-----------------------------------------------------------------
U win some...lose some...everything is not justified in this world.


mpai64   
Member since: Jun 04
Posts: 28
Location: Thane, India

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 26-07-04 04:19:44

Quote:
Orginally posted by Sam Jay


Thanks bighead .ur post was really encouraging.
To tell u guys abt my background.
I have done Diploma in Business Management from India and have 7 years of work experience in the field of finance,banking,accounts at very senior level.


Ok those of our members who r in the field of finance ,I have my next question..

Which course after getting my PR (MBA or CGA or CA from from canada )
shud i go for.Can somebody provide me the details.

What is the salary that one shud draw to ahve a reasonable standard of living ?

Thanks again big head



I fully agree with Mr. Big Head. I am also into Finance & Accounts, Banking background who is awaiting the PR from CHC. I do not regret my applying for PR. Canada is a land of opportunity with true Democracy unlike our banana republic with hypocracy. If you have the correct mind set with right attitude, you can succeed. Here the attitude counts a lot.
As far any Indian Degree does not get recognised in Canada. CA from Canada is as difficult process as Indian one as you need to work for a Audit Firm etc. But you can do CPA from US which is valid & recognised in Canada.

Regards,

MP



chandresh   
Member since: Mar 03
Posts: 2606
Location: Toronto

Post ID: #PID Posted on: 26-07-04 08:47:34

Quote:
Orginally posted by mpai64
CA from Canada is as difficult process as Indian one as you need to work for a Audit Firm etc. But you can do CPA from US which is valid & recognised in Canada.

Regards,

MP



Really???

Can you enlighten me how CA from India is not valid and not recognised in Canada vis a vis how CPA from USA is valid and recognised in Canada? I am both a CA from India and a CPA from USA and your inputs might be able to help me.

Chandresh


-----------------------------------------------------------------
Chandresh

Advice is free – lessons I charge for!!


Contributors: bighead(3) chandresh(2) Sam Jay(2) Kap(1) jake3d(1) Daks(1) NorthAlberta(1) mercury6(1) deepcb(1) rajcanada(1) BlueLobster(1) mpai64(1) rajand(1) Bobby73(1)



Jump to Page: < Previous  [ 1 ]  [ 2 ]  [ 3 ]    Next >

Discussions similar to: Is immigration to Canada really worth it??

Topic Forum Views Replies
Can anybody give Brief details for Student VISA
Student Visa 1507 1
How to bring my wife to canada
Family Class 1484 2
Has Immigration Process gone slow overall?
Ask Immigration Expert 2236 1
queries on funds,job,visual effects college
Study 1640 2
planning to move usa also parents r sponcered
Family Class 1772 2
PCC from other countries
Independent Category 1569 2
What about francophone immigration? ( 1 2 )
Ask Immigration Expert 1965 7
What about francophone immigration-Thank you Mr. Massood
Ask Immigration Expert 1236 0
Moving Immg. Papers from India to USA
Where to settle 1616 2
Move old-(1987) car to Canada?
Relocation 1704 3
Does it worth to Move from Toronto to Alberta ?
Life 2091 2
Family immigration
Independent Category 1488 1
About sponsoring family
Family Class 1625 0
Hi...!!!Regarding quebec immigration.
Ask Immigration Expert 1428 3
Canada or the US/ for students in the US with PR
Life 1789 2
Immigration from India to Canada ( 1 2 )
Ask Immigration Expert 2616 7
Poll: Help needed on decision to move to CANADA ( 1 2 )
Independent Category 3727 10
IT Project Manager looking towards moving to Alberta
Jobs 1455 1
GMAT Coaching
Study 1985 5
planning to move in May 2010 ( 1 2 3 )
Moving Soon 5059 18
BREAKING NEWS..: IMMIGRATION...
Family Class 2074 0
medical done and RPRF payment made - what next?
Independent Category 2115 1
Suggestion to improve the CD posts ( 1 2 )
Feedback and Comments 4288 9
USA citizen kid - planning to move to USA for study and settle down ( 1 2 )
USA 8141 10
Relocation Advice: is it worth the cost to move our furniture?
Moving Soon 2238 2
 


Share:
















Advertise Contact Us Privacy Policy and Terms of Usage FAQ
Canadian Desi
© 2001 Marg eSolutions


Site designed, developed and maintained by Marg eSolutions Inc.